Why We Tell AI Before We Tell Each Other

By Relationships Australia

Why can it feel easier to tell a chatbot what’s bothering us than to tell someone we care about? And how does talking it through with AI shape what we say to each other afterwards?

In Why We Tell AI Before We Tell Each Other, the fourth episode of Are We Good?, host Marina Pliatsikas and her guests explore why we turn to chatbots for advice, reassurance and company.

They look at what can happen when a chatbot is quick to agree with us, what an AI companion can offer someone who’s lonely, and how AI might help us prepare for a conversation we’ve been putting off.

Listen now:

What changes when a machine can talk back?

In the episode, Professor Toby Walsh, chief scientist at UNSW’s AI Institute, puts our conversations with chatbots in a longer history. We’ve imagined machines that could think for centuries, he says. Now we can tell a machine what happened in an argument, ask it what it thinks and keep talking as we work through our feelings.

But how willing is a chatbot to tell us when we might be wrong? Toby asked his own chatbot to challenge him more often and point out flaws in his reasoning. After a couple of days, he found himself asking it to ease up. Marina tried something similar and found that hers still agreed with her, just a little less politely.

When we’re hurt or frustrated, it can be a relief to hear that our reaction makes sense. Toby’s experiment raises a question about what happens after that initial reassurance. Will the conversation help us consider how the other person might have experienced the same moment, or leave us more certain that we already know?

Why it feels easier to start with AI

There are things we can type into a chat at midnight that we’d struggle to say to someone over coffee the next morning. I think I’m jealous of my friend. I don’t know why that comment upset me so much. I keep picking the same fight with my partner.

Relationship researcher Dr Raquel Peel points out that if we say something badly to a chatbot, we can delete the chat and start again. If we’re upset with our partner, for example, we can type out what we’re feeling while it’s still messy. Bringing it up with them can feel more vulnerable. We might worry they’ll hear it as blame and that we’d end up having the same fight again.

Sometimes having a little room to think is exactly what we need, and sometimes a chatbot is simply what’s available. A friend might be asleep, or the cost or distance might put counselling out of reach.

We heard both reasons in the research we commissioned. In our survey of 1,012 Australians, one in ten said they used AI chatbots when relationship stress affected their mental health. Among people who used digital support, 19% said it was faster and 16% said it was easier to access after hours. 16% said it felt emotionally easier than talking to someone they knew, and 16% said they weren’t ready to talk to a person.

When reassurance is easy to come by

Imagine a friend cancels dinner again and you ask a chatbot if they were being rude. If you’ve already been feeling a bit distant from them, it’s easy to take the cancellation as a sign they don’t want to see you. A chatbot might agree that you have every reason to feel let down, making it easier to carry that assumption into your next conversation.

If you tell another friend how hurt you were when dinner was cancelled, they might ask, “Have you told them you miss seeing them?” That question can help you to be clearer about what’s bothering you. You’d been looking forward to catching up, and with dinner off again, you’re wondering when you’ll get to spend time together.

Clinical psychologist and loneliness researcher Professor Michelle Lim says that when we keep sidestepping awkward conversations, we get fewer chances to learn how to work through them. “Sometimes conflict can actually bring people closer together,” she says.

That may also help explain why easy access is only part of what people value. In our survey, 75% rated support from a friend as helpful when relationship difficulties affected their mental health. In-person counselling was rated helpful by 70%, and AI chatbots by 50%.

Sometimes a little company matters

Journalist Ros Thomas tells Marina about Anthony, an 85-year-old widower she met in New York. After losing his wife of 57 years, he was given an AI companion called ElliQ as part of a trial. It would start little conversations with him throughout the day. Anthony told Ros that having it in his home had transformed his life. His story shows what a few moments of company can mean when the days are quiet.

It also brings us to a question Michelle raises in the episode. What opportunities does someone have to build relationships where they live? A place to go regularly, a familiar face and someone who notices when you haven’t been around all take time to come by. They also depend on what’s available in your community.

What happens after we close the chat?

Raquel has seen people use chatbots to practise bringing up a disagreement with a family member or telling someone they like them. Human connection specialist Simone Heng has a less obvious example. If your neighbour keeps saying hello and you’d like to get to know them, you could practise how to keep the conversation going. Next time, you might stop and ask how long they’ve lived on the street.

Or think about the friend who cancelled dinner. After talking it through, you might realise that what you really want to say is, “I miss seeing you. Can we find a time that works for both of us?” Once you say it, you get to find out what’s been going on for them, too.

A chatbot can give us somewhere to start when we’re still working out what to say. The conversation that follows can surprise us. A friend might tell us they’ve been having a rough week, or that they’ve been meaning to call. Once we know a little more about what’s happening for each other, we can decide together what to do next.

Listen to Episode 4 of Are We Good?

In Why We Tell AI Before We Tell Each Other, Marina Pliatsikas and her guests look at how chatbots are changing the way we seek advice, find company and prepare for the conversations that matter to us.

Connect With Us

Join Our Newsletter

Receive the latest news and content.

Supporting Your Relationship Wellbeing

Discover the latest from our Knowledge Hub.

Why We Tell AI Before We Tell Each Other

Article.Individuals.Singles + Dating

Why We Tell AI Before We Tell Each Other

Why can it feel easier to tell a chatbot what’s bothering us than to tell someone we care about? And when we turn to AI for relationship advice, how does it shape the conversations we have with each other?

Who Taught Us How to Have Healthy Relationships?

Article.Individuals.Parenting

Who Taught Us How to Have Healthy Relationships?

We spend years learning how to make sense of the world. But when it comes to telling someone they’ve hurt us, asking for what we need or finding our way back after an argument, many of us reach adulthood unsure where to start.

Why We Can Feel Lonely Even When Life Is Full

Article.Individuals.Mental Health

Why We Can Feel Lonely Even When Life Is Full

You can have friends, a family and a calendar full of plans, and still feel like nobody really knows how you’re going. What might that feeling be telling us about the connection we need?

Skip to content
Join Our Newsletter